In this article, Atalia Omer considers how the adoption by Harvard University of the IHRA ‘antisemitism’ definition, which conflates criticism of Israeli policies with antisemitism, has led the University to frame pro-Palestine actions at the university as ‘antisemitic’. She argues that this constitutes a threat not only to Palestine solidarity but to free speech and the defence of human rights more generally.
25 May 2025
I’m an Israeli professor. Why is my work in Harvard’s antisemitism report?
Atalia Omer
Harvard is conflating Jewish identity with political loyalty to Israel. That’s a dangerous mistake
The Guardian
Fri 9 May 2025
When I first saw the Harvard report on antisemitism and anti-Israel bias, I didn’t expect to find myself in it. But I did, albeit without my name, my scholarship, or even my identity as a Jewish Israeli academic being acknowledged.
The report was compiled and published in response to widespread pressure from donors and pro-Israel advocacy groups. It claims to document a crisis of antisemitism on campus. But what it actually reveals is Harvard’s willingness to redefine Jewish identity in narrow, ideological terms: to exclude and erase Jews who dissent from Zionism.
I know this because I am one of them. For several years, I taught in the Religion, Conflict, and Peace Initiative (RCPI) at Harvard Divinity School. Our program approached peacebuilding through deep engagement with histories of structural violence and power, with Palestine/Israel as our central case study. Our students read widely, traveled to the region, and met with a range of voices – including Jewish Israeli veterans from Breaking the Silence, Palestinian artists resisting cultural erasure, and Mizrahi and Ethiopian Jewish activists challenging racism within Israeli society.
It was, by design, intellectually and politically challenging. It exposed students to the complexity of the region and the diverse, often conflicting, ways Jews and Palestinians narrate their pasts and imagine their futures.
But according to the authors of Harvard’s report, this was not legitimate scholarship nor responsible pedagogy; it was, essentially, simply antisemitic ideological indoctrination.
How the report supposedly arrives at and justifies such characterizations of our program illustrates how slanderous distortions are routinely deployed to suppress the arguments and identities of ‘the wrong kind’ of Jews. The report quotes from public events we hosted as part of RCPI, including a webinar on my book about American Jewish activists who engage in Palestinian solidarity work because of—not in spite of—their Jewish identity. Rabbi Brant Rosen, a Reconstructionist rabbi and founder of Tzedek Chicago, and Dr Sara Roy, a distinguished scholar of Palestine and daughter of Holocaust survivors, offered thoughtful responses.
Yet the report reduced that event to a vague description of “one speaker” praising “Jewish pro-Palestinian activists,” ignoring that the speaker was me—a Jewish Israeli professor—and that my interlocutors were also Jewish. Rosen’s reflections on his disillusionment with Zionism were dismissed as a “conversion narrative,” as if spiritual or ethical evolution were evidence of antisemitism.
In another webinar I moderated, Rosen and the Jewish scholar Daniel Boyarin debated the place of Zionism in synagogue liturgy. Boyarin disagreed with Rosen’s liturgical revisions but affirmed their shared ethical commitments. The report cherry-picked Boyarin’s comment—“I am deeply in sympathy with your political and ethical positions”—to suggest the event lacked “viewpoint diversity.” The irony is hard to miss: a conversation between three Jews, from very different traditions, becomes evidence not of diversity, but of its absence.
This selective framing is neither accidental nor a one-off act of malice. It reflects a broader pattern: Harvard’s decision in January of this year to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, which conflates criticism of Israeli policies with antisemitism itself. In doing so, the university has not only taken steps to further suppress important political and ethical speech that confronts the reality of Israeli violence against Palestinians; it also effectively embraced a political litmus test for who counts as a legitimate Jew on campus.
It’s clear that I’m the ‘wrong kind of Jew’ at Harvard. At each juncture, my academic and political commitments placed me outside the bounds of acceptability. I was too critical, too engaged, too willing to challenge dominant narratives. And I am far from the only one.
The report goes further still. It dismisses not only the work, identities, and experiences of faculty and scholars but also the experiences of our Jewish students, including those who participated in our course’s study trip to Palestine/Israel. One Jewish student described the experience as “formative, painful, and powerful,” recounting the ways Israeli apartheid undermines not just politics but the very possibility of cultural life for Palestinians. The report presents this reflection not as evidence of learning, but as proof of indoctrination.
The implication is clear: Jewish students who come to critical conclusions about Israel are not independent thinkers. They’ve been misled. Manipulated. Infantilized.
Ironically, this is itself an antisemitic trope: that Jews cannot think for themselves unless they conform to a sanctioned ideology.
The report also erases the rich diversity of Jewish voices we brought into our classrooms. It claims our program focused on “non-mainstream Jewish perspectives,” dismissing people like Noam Shuster Eliassi, a Mizrahi Jewish Israeli comedian whose work was supported by our fellowship program and is now featured at the Sundance Film Festival. It ignores events that engaged deeply with Mizrahi and Ethiopian Jewish experiences, including our commemoration of the Israeli Black Panthers’ Passover Haggadah—a powerful symbol of anti-racist struggle in Israeli history.
And it entirely omits our programming on antisemitism itself, including a discussion of alternative definitions of antisemitism like the Jerusalem Declaration, which, unlike IHRA, carefully distinguishes between criticism of Israel and hatred of Jews.
In short, Harvard’s report does not just mischaracterize a program. It attempts to redraw the boundaries of Jewish legitimacy.
It sends a chilling message to students and faculty: if you are a Jew who questions Zionism, you are suspect. If you engage in solidarity with Palestinians, you do not belong. If your scholarship complicates the tidy moral narrative of a beleaguered Israel, you are not just unwelcome—you are dangerous.
This is not a defense of Jewish safety. It is an effort to police Jewish dissent.
But I refuse to be policed. I will continue to teach, write, and organize alongside Jews and Palestinians fighting for freedom, justice, and dignity. I will continue to challenge institutions that claim to defend against antisemitism while perpetuating other forms of racism and repression.
And I will do so not despite being a Jew, but because I am one.
IverCare Pharmacy: IverCare Pharmacy – cost of ivermectin cream
Login Beta138: Slot gacor Beta138 – Beta138
Slot game d?i thu?ng: Rut ti?n nhanh GK88 – Nha cai uy tin Vi?t Nam
Login Beta138: Bandar bola resmi – Situs judi resmi berlisensi
Slot game d?i thu?ng Ca cu?c tr?c tuy?n GK88 Rut ti?n nhanh GK88
Jollibet online sabong: Online gambling platform Jollibet – Online gambling platform Jollibet
Yüks?k RTP slotlar: Pinco casino mobil t?tbiq – Qeydiyyat bonusu Pinco casino
Pinco r?smi sayt: Pinco r?smi sayt – Pinco kazino
https://pinwinaz.pro/# Pinco il? real pul qazan
Link alternatif Abutogel: Abutogel login – Abutogel login
Swerte99 login: Swerte99 login – Swerte99 slots
Jiliko bonus: maglaro ng Jiliko online sa Pilipinas – Jiliko bonus
Mandiribet Situs judi online terpercaya Indonesia Bonus new member 100% Mandiribet
Slot oyunlar? Pinco-da: Uduslar? tez c?xar Pinco il? – Uduslar? tez c?xar Pinco il?
Swerte99 casino: Swerte99 – Swerte99 app
jollibet app: Jollibet online sabong – Online casino Jollibet Philippines
Link alternatif Mandiribet: Situs judi resmi berlisensi – Link alternatif Mandiribet
https://betawinindo.top/# Bonus new member 100% Beta138
Situs judi resmi berlisensi: Bandar bola resmi – Promo slot gacor hari ini
Bonus new member 100% Beta138 Login Beta138 Beta138
Swerte99 app: Swerte99 app – Swerte99 online gaming Pilipinas
Swerte99 casino: Swerte99 – Swerte99 login
Abutogel login: Abutogel – Situs togel online terpercaya
Kazino bonuslar? 2025 Az?rbaycan Yuks?k RTP slotlar Etibarl? onlayn kazino Az?rbaycanda
Onlayn rulet v? blackjack: Onlayn kazino Az?rbaycan – Kazino bonuslar? 2025 Az?rbaycan
Jackpot togel hari ini: Bandar togel resmi Indonesia – Link alternatif Abutogel
Jiliko casino: Jiliko casino – Jiliko slots
https://jilwin.pro/# Jiliko slots
Qeydiyyat bonusu Pinco casino: Pinco kazino – Yeni az?rbaycan kazino sayt?
Jiliko slots Jiliko login jilwin
Jiliko casino walang deposit bonus para sa Pinoy: Jiliko – Jiliko login
Swerte99: Swerte99 slots – Swerte99 online gaming Pilipinas
Onlayn rulet v? blackjack: Qeydiyyat bonusu Pinco casino – Onlayn rulet v? blackjack
Swerte99 casino Swerte99 casino Swerte99 casino
Tro choi n? hu GK88: Dang ky GK88 – Casino online GK88
Slot oyunlari Pinco-da: Pinco il? real pul qazan – Qeydiyyat bonusu Pinco casino
Swerte99 login: Swerte99 login – Swerte99 online gaming Pilipinas
Cá cu?c tr?c tuy?n GK88: Trò choi n? hu GK88 – Slot game d?i thu?ng
Login Beta138 Bandar bola resmi Slot gacor Beta138
jollibet app: jollibet app – 1winphili
maglaro ng Jiliko online sa Pilipinas: Jiliko casino walang deposit bonus para sa Pinoy – Jiliko app
Bandar togel resmi Indonesia: Situs togel online terpercaya – Situs togel online terpercaya
jollibet app jollibet app jollibet
Situs togel online terpercaya: Bandar togel resmi Indonesia – Abutogel login
https://swertewin.life/# Swerte99 slots
GK88: Link vao GK88 m?i nh?t – Casino online GK88
top 10 online pharmacy in india: best india pharmacy – top 10 online pharmacy in india
north harbour pharmacy propecia get cialis online pharmacy MediDirect USA
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
isotretinoin from mexico: safe mexican online pharmacy – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: medication from mexico pharmacy – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – reputable indian online pharmacy
india online pharmacy: online shopping pharmacy india – Online medicine order
https://mexicanpharmacyhub.com/# Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Indian Meds One п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india indian pharmacy
online pharmacy pyridium: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
indian pharmacy paypal: Indian Meds One – top online pharmacy india
amoxicillin mexico online pharmacy: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Indian Meds One Indian Meds One reputable indian online pharmacy
kroger pharmacy near me: online pharmacy viagra – asda pharmacy ventolin
best prices on finasteride in mexico: get viagra without prescription from mexico – buy cialis from mexico
https://mexicanpharmacyhub.shop/# Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Indian Meds One: mail order pharmacy india – india pharmacy mail order
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – online pharmacy zovirax cream
buy prescription drugs from india: india online pharmacy – Indian Meds One
uk online viagra pharmacy MediDirect USA ed pharmacy viagra
ondansetron online pharmacy: people’s pharmacy generic wellbutrin – kamagra oral jelly online pharmacy
buy meds from mexican pharmacy: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – sildenafil mexico online
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – indian trail pharmacy
https://medidirectusa.com/# vet pharmacy online
indian pharmacy cheapest online pharmacy india Indian Meds One
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – Online medicine order
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – Indian Meds One
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – Indian Meds One
india pharmacy Indian Meds One Indian Meds One
india pharmacy mail order: Indian Meds One – best india pharmacy
reputable mexican pharmacies online: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: gabapentin mexican pharmacy – trusted mexican pharmacy
https://mexicanpharmacyhub.shop/# medicine in mexico pharmacies
clarithromycin online pharmacy: MediDirect USA – ivermectin pharmacy uk
propecia online pharmacy reviews: griseofulvin online pharmacy – gabapentin pharmacy prices
MediDirect USA MediDirect USA reputable online pharmacy cialis
india pharmacy: indian pharmacy – india online pharmacy
Indian Meds One: world pharmacy india – Indian Meds One
Indian Meds One: reputable indian online pharmacy – Indian Meds One
top 10 online pharmacy in india buy prescription drugs from india indian pharmacies safe
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – flomax pharmacy
https://sildenapeak.com/# sildenafil citrate online pharmacy
Tadalify: how much does cialis cost with insurance – Tadalify
online viagra pills: buy viagra in singapore – sildenafil for sale usa
Tadalify: Tadalify – cialis purchase canada
cialis store in philippines Tadalify cialis no prescription
price of 100mg viagra: SildenaPeak – viagra 300mg
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – sildenafil tablets 100mg buy
http://tadalify.com/# cialis 50mg
cialis super active plus: cheap cialis by post – Tadalify
ED treatment without doctor visits Men’s sexual health solutions online Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging
Tadalify: Tadalify – cialis 10mg price
benefits of tadalafil over sidenafil: Tadalify – cialis leg pain
cialis for sale in canada: how long does cialis stay in your system – cialis canada free sample
viagra online free shipping canadian online pharmacy generic viagra can i buy viagra over the counter in canada
Tadalify: where to buy generic cialis – prices cialis
KamaMeds: Kamagra oral jelly USA availability – KamaMeds
https://sildenapeak.shop/# SildenaPeak
canada drug cialis: Tadalify – canada cialis for sale
cialis for sale in toront ontario: when does cialis go off patent – generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg from india
Tadalify: adcirca tadalafil – Tadalify
Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging ED treatment without doctor visits ED treatment without doctor visits
Kamagra oral jelly USA availability: Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men – Safe access to generic ED medication
SildenaPeak: how to buy sildenafil – SildenaPeak
Tadalify: Tadalify – where can i get cialis
tadalafil and ambrisentan newjm 2015 Tadalify Tadalify
http://tadalify.com/# Tadalify
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – viagra brand name
cialis 80 mg dosage: generic cialis available in canada – Tadalify
Non-prescription ED tablets discreetly shipped: ED treatment without doctor visits – Safe access to generic ED medication
KamaMeds Kamagra oral jelly USA availability Safe access to generic ED medication
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – SildenaPeak
best price for sildenafil 20 mg: SildenaPeak – SildenaPeak
SildenaPeak: viagra medication cost – buy online viagra
https://kamameds.shop/# Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging
Tadalify Tadalify where to get free samples of cialis
cialis ingredients: Tadalify – buy cialis without doctor prescription
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – sildenafil canada buy
cialis free trial voucher: why is cialis so expensive – Tadalify
where can i buy viagra canada: sildenafil us pharmacy – buy viagra no prescription online
cost of sildenafil in canada viagra online from india viagra mexico cost
Safe access to generic ED medication: Men’s sexual health solutions online – Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men
Kamagra oral jelly USA availability: ED treatment without doctor visits – Non-prescription ED tablets discreetly shipped
http://kamameds.com/# Men’s sexual health solutions online
Safe access to generic ED medication: Kamagra oral jelly USA availability – Compare Kamagra with branded alternatives
SildenaPeak: buy viagra in usa online – SildenaPeak
cialis professional review cialis buy online cialis dopoxetine
Tadalify: Tadalify – canada cialis for sale
cialis effectiveness: Tadalify – cialis for blood pressure
how to buy generic clomid: FertiCare Online – FertiCare Online
ClearMeds Pharmacy: – buy antibiotics
how to get ed pills online ed drugs online ed meds
buy antibiotics for tooth infection: ClearMeds – buy antibiotics
https://clearmedspharm.com/# buy antibiotics online
https://vitalcorepharm.com/# ed pills
ClearMeds Pharmacy: cheap antibiotics – buy antibiotics online for uti
cheap antibiotics buy antibiotics online ClearMeds Pharmacy
best online foreign pharmacy: TrueMeds Pharmacy – TrueMeds
http://truemedspharm.com/# TrueMeds
ClearMeds Pharmacy: antibiotics over the counter – buy antibiotics online safely
buy antibiotics online for uti buy antibiotics
TrueMeds Pharmacy: TrueMeds – TrueMeds
http://clearmedspharm.com/#
https://clearmedspharm.com/# cheap antibiotics
buy antibiotics online for uti: – buy antibiotics online
buy antibiotics online safely ClearMeds ClearMeds Pharmacy
buy erectile dysfunction pills online: ed pills – ed pills
TrueMeds: TrueMeds – safe online pharmacies in canada
ClearMeds Pharmacy antibiotics over the counter buy antibiotics
TrueMeds: TrueMeds – TrueMeds
: buy antibiotics online for uti – cheap antibiotics
https://vitalcorepharm.com/# VitalCore
https://vitalcorepharm.shop/# ed pills
BluePharma livraison rapide et confidentielle viagra generique efficace
kamagra 100 mg prix compétitif en ligne: commander kamagra en toute confidentialité – PharmaLibre France
Pharmacie sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne fiable
pharmacie en ligne pas cher acheter medicaments en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne fiable
pharmacie en ligne france: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – trouver un médicament en pharmacie
viagra femme: Le gГ©nГ©rique de Viagra – Blue Pharma
https://bluepharmafrance.shop/# BluePharma
kamagra en ligne France sans ordonnance commander kamagra en toute confidentialite commander kamagra en toute confidentialite
pharmacie en ligne pas cher: tadalafil sans ordonnance – médicament contre la dysfonction érectile
cialis sans ordonnance: medicament contre la dysfonction erectile – pharmacie en ligne france fiable
tadalafil prix cialis generique pas cher cialis generique pas cher
https://intimapharmafrance.shop/# Intima Pharma
https://pharmalibrefrance.shop/# kamagra
acheter kamagra pas cher livraison rapide: kamagra gel oral livraison discrete France – commander kamagra en toute confidentialite
medicament contre la dysfonction erectile cialis sans ordonnance IntimaPharma
http://bluepharmafrance.com/# Viagra homme prix en pharmacie sans ordonnance
pilule bleue en ligne: Viagra 100mg prix – viagra 100 mg prix abordable France
cialis generique pas cher cialis sans ordonnance pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
https://bluepharmafrance.com/# viagra generique efficace
https://pharmalibrefrance.shop/# kamagra oral jelly
kamagra 100 mg prix competitif en ligne: Pharma Libre – PharmaLibre