Masha Gessen, a Russian-American Jewish professor, won a prize in the name of Hannah Arendt, but when German sponsors of the prize heard his voice, so reminiscent of Arendt’s, they dissociated themselves from the prize and so too did the German town officials where the prize was to be awarded. Gessen’s comparison of human rights abuses by Nazi Germany and Israel deserves to be heard. Germany’s attempt to silence it only contributes to the injustices that Arendt spoke so eloquently about. The original report in the Washington Post can be found here.
Masha Gessen won a ‘political thought’ prize. Then they wrote on Gaza.
A Q&A with the journalist, after two sponsors of the Hannah Arendt Prize withdrew their support

By Laura Wagner
December 14, 2023 at 12:51 p.m. EST
Masha Gessen was set to travel Wednesday from New York to Bremen, Germany, to accept an award Friday named for political philosopher Hannah Arendt, whose writing on totalitarianism made her a celebrated thinker of the 20th century.
Then came news that two sponsors of the event had pulled out, citing Gessen’s Dec. 9 New Yorker essay titled “In the shadow of the Holocaust,”a reflection from Berlin on what’s happened since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel. Gessen criticizes Germany’s policies relating to Israel, examines the country’s regulation of Holocaust remembrance, and compares the suffering of Palestinians in Gaza to that of Jews in Nazi-occupied Eastern Europe.
“Presumably, the more fitting term ‘ghetto’ would have drawn fire for comparing the predicament of besieged Gazans to that of ghettoized Jews,” Gessen wrote. “It also would have given us the language to describe what is happening in Gaza now. The ghetto is being liquidated.”
This excerpt “implies that Israel aims to liquidate Gaza like a Nazi ghetto,” the left-leaning Heinrich Böll Foundation wrote in its withdrawal from co-sponsoring the award. “This statement is not an offer for open discussion; it does not help to understand the conflict in the Middle East.”
The news was first reported by Germany’s Die Zeit newspaper. Administrators of Bremen’s town hall withdrew the venue for the prize ceremony, according to the Hannah Arendt Association for Political Thought, which confers the prize.
Gessen, who is Jewish, is a celebrated thinker in their own right, and the author of books about repressive political regimes in the United States and Russia, the winner of Germany’s 2019 Leipzig Book Prize for European Understanding, and a professor at the Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism in New York.
The Hannah Arendt Association wrote in a statement: “We find it remarkable that the public debate about understanding and condemning Hamas’s terrorist attacks on Israel and Israel’s bombing of Gaza is being blocked by boycotting a political thinker who is trying to bring knowledge, insight and sharp thinking to this debate.”
Gessen spoke to The Washington Post Wednesday evening from John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York, as they were preparing to fly to Bremen, where a smaller award ceremony in a different venue was rescheduled for Saturday. The interview has been lightly edited for length and clarity.
Q: When and how did you hear the news?
A: I woke up to a message from one of the organizers from the Hannah Arendt Association. I never heard from the Heinrich Böll Foundation. Nobody ever sent me a statement, nobody ever asked me for clarification, nothing. All the other details — aside from the foundation and the city pulling out — I have been learning from the media.
Q: Are you surprised by the foundation’s decision?
A: Well, yes and no. I was in Berlin reporting this piece, and I mentioned — as a joke that’s not really a joke — to some friends that I might get my Hannah Arendt Prize revoked over this. They assured me that that wasn’t possible, so I trusted their intuition. Even people I know in Germany who have been dealing with this on a continuous basis for the past several years continue to be shocked by the craziness of this — people’s speech being shut down, Jews being denounced as antisemitic for criticizing Israeli policies, et cetera.
Q: Can you describe how Germany’s regulation of Holocaust remembrance and discussion limits how people talk about what is happening in Gaza, the West Bank and Israel?
A: I think the most important part of this memory culture — that has effectively become memory policy — is the insistence on the singularity of the Holocaust. Singularity to such an extent that it is not permissible to draw any comparisons between Nazi policies and any contemporary policies, the Holocaust and any other contemporary events. The reason that I think this is misguided and dangerous is because the only way we can learn from history is if we compare it to the present. That’s actually our own tool. We’re not any smarter or better or more moral than the people who lived 100 years ago. The only thing that we have that they didn’t have is an awareness that the Holocaust was possible and remains possible. It’s a lesson, not a particularly complicated one.
Q: Germany has been criticized for its unconditional support for Israel’s military assault on Gaza, and for its crackdown on speech and pro-Palestinian protests. Museum shows, book talks and other art events have been canceled recently. Does this episode over the Hannah Arendt Prize fit into this pattern?
A: It’s a little bit early to say. This just happened today. The Heinrich Böll Foundation and the city of Bremen have pulled out, but the Hannah Arendt organization itself has not rescinded the prize. So, that’s why I’m going there. I feel like if these people are standing by me, then I should certainly stand by them.
Q: In your essay, you quote Arendt. In 1948, Arendt compared a Jewish-Israeli political party to the Nazi party. You suggest that such a statement today would be a “clear violation” of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism. Is there some absurdity here, given the namesake of the prize? How are you thinking about this discrepancy?
A: Absurdity I think is a pretty good way of putting it. As I said, I was in Berlin just a month ago working on this. In a sense it was like a controlled experiment, but I still couldn’t quite believe this would happen.
Q: On Friday, Russia issued a warrant for your arrest on the charge of “spreading false information about the Russian Armed Forces,” for your criticism of Russian President Vladimir Putin and the atrocities the Russian military committed in Ukraine. Do you see any parallels between these two state efforts to limit speech?
A: I can’t not see parallels because they’re both things that affect me and my plans, how I move through the world, even possibly the money I was counting on coming in at the end of the year.
Someone I very much like and respect texted me, “So many badges of honor, you’re going to need a bigger shirt to pin them on.” That’s a funny way of looking at it, and I think in a sense these are badges of honor, but it’s not pleasant. They both kind of make me feel like space is closing in — with Russia because it limits my ability to travel not just to Russia but to various places in the world, and with Germany because … generally speaking, once you’re canceled in Germany, you’re really canceled. So [not being] able to participate in the same way in cultural events is saddening.
Q: How does this pattern of suppressing what can be said about Israel and Gaza play into the overwhelming military assault on Gaza, which has sparked a debate about whether Israel is committing genocide?
A: I’m not convinced that genocide is the right term. I think ethnic cleansing is the right term. But in any case, I think it’s likely that crimes against humanity are being committed there.
This is something I want to mention: This whole idea of crimes against humanity — like the idea of genocide — these are concepts that came out of World War II and the Holocaust. When we’re thinking about whether a crime against humanity has been committed, or if a genocide has been committed, we’re performing the act of comparing the Holocaust to current events. That’s a foundational stone of our contemporary international legal system.
So to ban that kind of comparison is to try to [throw] a wrench in the entire works of international humanitarian law, and I think Israel does that quite advisedly. That’s why they’ve invested so much money and time and energy in silencing speech critical of Israel, so even the idea that Israel can be held responsible for crimes against humanity is discredited before it’s ever articulated.
Q: In the United States, universities and other cultural groups formally and informally police speech related to Israel and Gaza. How do you compare the suppression happening in the United States to that of Germany?
A: I’m really glad you asked that question because I think that, legally, the situation in the United States is not that different from the situation in Germany. The House has just passed a resolution equating anti-Zionism with antisemitism. New York state has an executive order banning BDS [the boycotting and sanctioning of Israel]. The State Department has adopted the IHRA definition of antisemitism. In 2019, Donald Trump signed an executive order that withholds federal funds from programs and universities that “fail” to protect people from antisemitism.
I’m afraid that a fight over federal funding is something that’s going to come now on the heels of the congressional hearings, in which university presidents are grilled McCarthy-style. The biggest reason that we haven’t felt the impact of such legislations and resolutions as strongly in the United States as they have in Germany is because there’s just much less funding involved in cultural programs in the United States. But there have, of course, been individual cases of people not being able to take jobs — and losing their jobs — under the provisions of these anti-BDS laws. I really want people to read my essay because I want people to be aware that we have already laid the foundations for quite similar things to happen in the United States.
Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me.
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.
ivermectin side effects on kidneys: ivermectin tablets order – IverCare Pharmacy
Uduslari tez çixar Pinco il?: Kazino bonuslari 2025 Az?rbaycan – Onlayn rulet v? blackjack
Link alternatif Beta138: Live casino Indonesia – Bandar bola resmi
Slot gacor hari ini: Mandiribet login – Slot gacor hari ini
Onlayn kazino Az?rbaycan: Uduslar? tez c?xar Pinco il? – Slot oyunlar? Pinco-da
Yuks?k RTP slotlar Qeydiyyat bonusu Pinco casino Pinco kazino
Jiliko casino: Jiliko app – Jiliko casino
Pinco casino mobil t?tbiq: Uduslar? tez c?xar Pinco il? – Uduslar? tez c?xar Pinco il?
jollibet Online gambling platform Jollibet Online betting Philippines
jilwin: Jiliko – Jiliko casino
Etibarl? onlayn kazino Az?rbaycanda: Canl? krupyerl? oyunlar – Etibarl? onlayn kazino Az?rbaycanda
https://abutowin.icu/# Link alternatif Abutogel
Abutogel login Abutogel login Abutogel login
Kazino bonuslari 2025 Az?rbaycan: Onlayn kazino Az?rbaycan – Kazino bonuslari 2025 Az?rbaycan
Jackpot togel hari ini: Jackpot togel hari ini – Abutogel login
jollibet app: Online casino Jollibet Philippines – jollibet app
Slot gacor hari ini: Live casino Mandiribet – Situs judi online terpercaya Indonesia
Judi online deposit pulsa Bonus new member 100% Mandiribet Mandiribet
Slot game d?i thu?ng: Ðang ký GK88 – Nhà cái uy tín Vi?t Nam
Swerte99 slots: Swerte99 login – Swerte99
https://swertewin.life/# Swerte99 casino walang deposit bonus para sa Pinoy
Bandar togel resmi Indonesia Abutogel Jackpot togel hari ini
Link vào GK88 m?i nh?t: Ðang ký GK88 – Link vào GK88 m?i nh?t
Slot gacor Beta138: Live casino Indonesia – Bonus new member 100% Beta138
Abutogel Situs togel online terpercaya Link alternatif Abutogel
Jiliko login: maglaro ng Jiliko online sa Pilipinas – Jiliko app
Live casino Mandiribet: Slot gacor hari ini – Slot gacor hari ini
https://mandiwinindo.site/# Judi online deposit pulsa
Online betting Philippines Online betting Philippines Online gambling platform Jollibet
Online gambling platform Jollibet: jollibet casino – jollibet login
Jiliko: Jiliko casino walang deposit bonus para sa Pinoy – Jiliko bonus
https://gkwinviet.company/# Ca cu?c tr?c tuy?n GK88
Casino online GK88: Slot game d?i thu?ng – Nhà cái uy tín Vi?t Nam
Mandiribet: Mandiribet – Situs judi resmi berlisensi
Slot oyunlar? Pinco-da Pinco il? real pul qazan Onlayn rulet v? blackjack
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – Indian Meds One
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
п»їmexican pharmacy Mexican Pharmacy Hub cheap cialis mexico
https://medidirectusa.com/# Claritin
fenofibrate online pharmacy price: propecia pharmacy price – MediDirect USA
best mexican online pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
MediDirect USA: naturxheal family pharmacy & health store-doral – rx clinic pharmacy
Mexican Pharmacy Hub Mexican Pharmacy Hub Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
https://mexicanpharmacyhub.com/# mexican rx online
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
Indian Meds One indian pharmacy Indian Meds One
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – real viagra online pharmacy
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: rybelsus from mexican pharmacy – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – Gyne-Lotrimin
Indian Meds One: Indian Meds One – indian pharmacy online
trusted mexican pharmacy Mexican Pharmacy Hub order azithromycin mexico
http://indianmedsone.com/# Indian Meds One
world pharmacy india: Indian Meds One – Indian Meds One
indian pharmacy paypal: Indian Meds One – reputable indian online pharmacy
super rx pharmacy online pharmacy cytotec no prescription care rx pharmacy
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
Mexican Pharmacy Hub: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – Mexican Pharmacy Hub
http://indianmedsone.com/# Indian Meds One
Mexican Pharmacy Hub Mexican Pharmacy Hub prescription drugs mexico pharmacy
MediDirect USA: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
MediDirect USA: methotrexate prices pharmacy – mexican pharmacy colchicine
mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs: Mexican Pharmacy Hub – mexican pharmaceuticals online
online pharmacy review: MediDirect USA – MediDirect USA
roadrunner pharmacy mexico pharmacy ambien MediDirect USA
https://indianmedsone.com/# Indian Meds One
Indian Meds One: top 10 online pharmacy in india – reputable indian online pharmacy
pharmacy website india: Indian Meds One – Indian Meds One
Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men Online sources for Kamagra in the United States ED treatment without doctor visits
best price for cialis: cialis professional ingredients – Tadalify
compare sildenafil prices: sildenafil 50 mg cost – SildenaPeak
https://sildenapeak.com/# SildenaPeak
Compare Kamagra with branded alternatives: Sildenafil oral jelly fast absorption effect – Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging
sildenafil pills online SildenaPeak SildenaPeak
Non-prescription ED tablets discreetly shipped: Compare Kamagra with branded alternatives – Kamagra reviews from US customers
SildenaPeak: 150 mg viagra online – discount viagra online canada
where can i buy cialis on line: how long does cialis last 20 mg – where to buy cialis in canada
Men’s sexual health solutions online Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging ED treatment without doctor visits
Kamagra oral jelly USA availability: Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men – ED treatment without doctor visits
https://tadalify.com/# Tadalify
sildenafil 100 capsules: SildenaPeak – viagra where to buy over the counter
Kamagra reviews from US customers Sildenafil oral jelly fast absorption effect Men’s sexual health solutions online
sildenafil 50mg tablets uk: SildenaPeak – where do i get viagra
SildenaPeak: online pharmacy australia viagra – SildenaPeak
where to get free samples of cialis Tadalify Tadalify
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – viagra capsule
https://sildenapeak.shop/# where to buy otc sildenafil
SildenaPeak: viagra rx coupon – SildenaPeak
SildenaPeak: SildenaPeak – best viagra pills india
online pharmacy australia viagra SildenaPeak SildenaPeak
SildenaPeak: buy viagra in usa online – female viagra for sale uk
Non-prescription ED tablets discreetly shipped: Fast-acting ED solution with discreet packaging – Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men
https://tadalify.com/# Tadalify
buy viagra tablet SildenaPeak where to purchase viagra in canada
Kamagra reviews from US customers: Compare Kamagra with branded alternatives – Online sources for Kamagra in the United States
Compare Kamagra with branded alternatives: Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men – Sildenafil oral jelly fast absorption effect
when is the best time to take cialis Tadalify Tadalify
Online sources for Kamagra in the United States: ED treatment without doctor visits – Online sources for Kamagra in the United States
tadalafil long term usage: does cialis make you harder – Tadalify
https://kamameds.com/# Sildenafil oral jelly fast absorption effect
cialis samples for physicians: original cialis online – cialis dosage for bph
Sildenafil oral jelly fast absorption effect Online sources for Kamagra in the United States Affordable sildenafil citrate tablets for men
Tadalify: when does tadalafil go generic – cialis slogan
Kamagra reviews from US customers: Safe access to generic ED medication – Kamagra oral jelly USA availability
how to buy viagra no prescription: SildenaPeak – SildenaPeak
TrueMeds: buy drugs from canada – TrueMeds
https://vitalcorepharm.com/# boner pills online
ClearMeds buy antibiotics for tooth infection
TrueMeds Pharmacy: TrueMeds – best canadian pharmacy
TrueMeds: TrueMeds – TrueMeds Pharmacy
TrueMeds: TrueMeds – TrueMeds Pharmacy
canadian pharmacy no prescription cheap scripts pharmacy canadian pharmacy coupon code
http://clearmedspharm.com/#
buy antibiotics for tooth infection: buy antibiotics – ClearMeds
ed pills VitalCore erectile dysfunction drugs online
my canadian pharmacy: TrueMeds Pharmacy – cheap online pharmacy
cheap antibiotics: antibiotics over the counter – cheap antibiotics
antibiotics over the counter buy antibiotics online safely buy antibiotics online for uti
Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good. https://www.gate.io/share/XwNAUwgM
TrueMeds: TrueMeds – TrueMeds Pharmacy
http://vitalcorepharm.com/# VitalCore Pharmacy
: buy antibiotics online –
buy antibiotics for tooth infection buy antibiotics online for uti antibiotics over the counter
VitalCore: ed pills – buying ed pills online
pharmacie en ligne france: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
viagra femme viagra 100 mg prix abordable France pilule bleue en ligne
viagra 100 mg prix abordable France: livraison rapide et confidentielle – viagra générique efficace
https://intimapharmafrance.shop/# commander cialis discretement
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
cialis sans ordonnance tadalafil prix Intima Pharma
viagra femme: sildenafil citrate 100 mg – Viagra 100 mg sans ordonnance
PharmaExpress France: pharmacie en ligne – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
IntimaPharma France IntimaPharma France pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
kamagra oral jelly: PharmaLibre France – PharmaLibre
https://pharmalibrefrance.com/# kamagra gel oral livraison discrete France
IntimaPharma: commander cialis discretement – tadalafil 20 mg en ligne
tadalafil sans ordonnance trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie tadalafil 20 mg en ligne
Viagra gГ©nГ©rique sans ordonnance en pharmacie: viagra generique efficace – viagra generique efficace
kamagra gel oral livraison discrete France PharmaLibre France kamagra gel oral livraison discrete France
https://pharmalibrefrance.com/# PharmaLibre
kamagra oral jelly: Pharma Libre – acheter kamagra pas cher livraison rapide
acheter kamagra pas cher livraison rapide commander kamagra en toute confidentialite commander kamagra en toute confidentialite
hargatoto alternatif: hargatoto login – hargatoto slot